The staging of melanoma has undergone tremendous revision and change since the initial pathologic descriptions of the disease. Here, the recent AJCC revisions are included. In addition, there is an ever burgeoning collection of prognostic factors that may lead to improved surveillance and treatment for this deadly disease.
STAGING PROGNOSTIC FACTORS
Solitary melanoma confined to dermis or subcutaneous fat
Tumor infiltrating lymphocytes
COMMONLY USED TERMS
(2002 American Joint Committee on Cancer Staging System)
Final version of the American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma.
Balch CM, Buzaid AC, Soong SJ, Atkins MB, Cascinelli N, Coit DG, Fleming ID, Gershenwald JE, Houghton A Jr, Kirkwood JM, McMasters KM, Mihm MF, Morton DL, Reintgen DS, Ross MI, Sober A, Thompson JA, Thompson JF.
Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, MD, USA.
J Clin Oncol 2001 Aug 15;19(16):3635-48 Abstract quote
PURPOSE: To revise the staging system for cutaneous melanoma under the auspices of the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The prognostic factors analysis described in the companion publication (this issue), as well as evidence from the published literature, was used to assemble the tumor-node-metastasis criteria and stage grouping for the melanoma staging system.
RESULTS: Major changes include (1) melanoma thickness and ulceration but not level of invasion to be used in the T category (except for T1 melanomas); (2) the number of metastatic lymph nodes rather than their gross dimensions and the delineation of clinically occult (ie, microscopic) versus clinically apparent (ie, macroscopic) nodal metastases to be used in the N category; (3) the site of distant metastases and the presence of elevated serum lactic dehydrogenase to be used in the M category; (4) an upstaging of all patients with stage I, II, and III disease when a primary melanoma is ulcerated; (5) a merging of satellite metastases around a primary melanoma and in-transit metastases into a single staging entity that is grouped into stage III disease; and (6) a new convention for defining clinical and pathologic staging so as to take into account the staging information gained from intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel node biopsy.
CONCLUSION: This revision will become official with publication of the sixth edition of the AJCC Cancer Staging Manual in the year 2002.
COMPARISON OF THE 1997 AND 2002 STAGING SYSTEMS (Adapted from Skin and Aging 2002:39.)
FACTOR 1997 SYSTEM 2002 SYSTEM COMMENTS Thickness Secondary prognostic factor; thresholds of 0.75, 1.50, and 4.0 mm Primary determinant of T staging; thresholds of 1.0, 2.0, 4.0 mm Correlation of metastatic risk is a continuous variable Level of invasion Primary determinant of T staging Used only for defining T1 melanomas Correlation only significant for thin lesions; variability in interpretation Ulceration Not included Included as second determinant of T and N staging Signifies a locally advanced lesion; dominant prognostic factor for grouping Stages I, II, III Satellite metastases In T category In N category Merged with in-transit lesions Thick melanomas (>4mm) Stage III Stage IIC Stage II defined as regional metastases Dimensions of nodal metastases Dominant determinant of N staging Not used No evidence of significant prognostic correlation Number of nodal metastases Not included Primary determinant of N staging Thresholds of 1 vs. 2-3 vs. greater than or equal to 4 nodes Metastatic tumor burden Not included Included as a second determinant of N staging Clinically occult (microscopic) vs. clinically apparent (macroscopic) nodal volume Lung metastases Merged with all other visceral metastases Separate category as M1b Has a somewhat better prognosis than other visceral metastases Elevated serum LDH Not included Included as a second determinant of M staging Clincal vs. pathologic staging Did not account for sentinel node technology Sentinel node results incorporated into definition of pathologic staging Large variability in outcome between clinical and pathologic staging; pathologic staging encouraged prior to entry into clinical trials
STAGE HISTOLOGICAL FEATURES AND TNM CLASSIFICATION OVERALL SURVIVAL
5 YEARS 10 YEARS 0 Intraepithelial/in situ melanoma (TisN0M0) 100% 100% IA </= 1 mm without ulceration and Clark level II/III (T1aN0M0) 95% 88% IB </= 1 mm with ulceration or level IV/V (T1bN0M0) 91% 83% 1.01-2 mm without ulceration (T2aN0M0) 89% 79% IIA 1.01-2 mm with ulceration (T2bN0M0) 77% 64% 2.01-4 mm without ulceration (T3aN0M0) 79% 64% IIB 2.01-4 mm with ulceration (T3bN0M0) 63% 51% >4 mm without ulceration (T4aN0M0) 67% 54% IIC >4 mm with ulceration (T4bN0M0) 45% 32% IIIA Single regional nodal micrometastasis, nonulcerated primary
69% 63% 2-3 microscopic regional nodes, nonulcerated primary (T1-4aN2aM0) 63% 57% IIIB Single regional nodal micrometastasis, ulcerated primary (T1-4bN1aM0) 53% 38% 2-3 microscopic regional nodes, ulcerated primary (T1-4bN2aM0) 50% 36% Single regional nodal macrometastasis, nonulcerated primary (T1-4aN1bM0) 59% 48% 2-3 macroscopic regional nodes, nonulcerated primary (T1-4aN2bM0) 46% 39% In-transit met(s)/satellite lesion(s) without metastatic lymph nodes (T1-4a/bN2cM0) 30-50% IIIC Single macroscopic regional node, ulcerated primary (T1-4bN1bM0) 29% 24% 2-3 macroscopic regional nodes, ulcerated primary (T1-4bN2bM0) 24% 15% 4 or more metastatic nodes, matted nodes/gross extracapsular extension, or in-transit met(s)/satellite(s) and metastatic ndoes (any T N3M0) 27% 18% IV Distant skin, subcutaneous, or nodal mets with normal LDH
(any T any N M1a)
59% 19% 16% Lung mets with normal LDH (any T any N M1b) 57% 7% 3% All other visceral mets with normal LDH or any distant mets with increased LDH (any T any N M1c) 41% 9% 6%
STAGING-1998 REVISION OF AJCC
PRIMARY TUMOR (pT)
Stage Characterization pTX Primary tumor cannot be assessed pT0 No evidence of primary tumor pTis Melanoma in situ, not an invasive lesion (Clark's level I) pT1 Tumor 0.75 mm or less in thickness and invades the papillary dermis (Clark's level II) pT2 Tumor more than 0.75 mm but not more than 1.5 mm in thickness and/or invades to the papillary reticular-dermal interface (Clark's level III) pT3 Tumor more than 1.5 mm but not more than 4 mm in thickness and/or invades the reticular dermis (Clark's level IV) pT3a Tumor more than 1.5 but not more than 3 mm in thickness pT3b Tumor more than 3 mm but not more than 4 mm in thickness pT4 Tumor more than 4 mm in thickness and/or invades the subcutaneous tissue pT4a Tumor more than 4 mm in thickness and/or invades the subcutaneous tissue pT4b Satellite(s) within 2 cm of primary tumor
LYMPH NODE (N)
Stage Characterization NX Regional lymph nodes cannot be assessed N0 No regional lymph node metastasis N1 Metastases 3 cm or less in greatest dimension in any regional lymph node(s) N2 Metastases more than 3 cm in greatest dimension in any regional lymph node(s) and/or in transit metastases N2a Metastases more than 3 cm in greatest dimension in any regional lymph node(s) N2b In-transit metastases N2c Both (N2a and N2b)
DISTANT METASTASES (M)
Stage Characterization MX Presence of distant metastases cannot be assessed M0 No distant metastases M1 Distant Metastases M1a Distant metastases in skin or subcutaneous tissue or lymph node(s) beyond the regional lymph nodes M1b Visceral metastases
Stage Characterization I pT1, N0, M0
pT2, N0, M0
II pT3, N0, M0
pT4, N0, M0
III Any pT, N1, M0
Any pT, N2, M0
IV Any pT, Any N, M1
PROGNOSIS AND TREATMENT CHARACTERIZATION PROGNOSTIC FACTORS OVERVIEW
These parameters have been cited as having prognostic significance:
Vertical growth phase
Depth of invasion
Lack of Relevant Information for Tumor Staging in Pathology Reports of Primary Cutaneous Melanoma
Klaus J. Busam
Am J Clin Pathol 2001;115:743-746 Abstract quote
For the T classification of primary cutaneous melanoma, the current American Joint Committee on Cancer staging (AJCC) system relies on tumor thickness and level of invasion. A new T classification has been proposed based on thickness and ulceration. The slides and reports of 135 departmental pathology consultations of patients referred to a major cancer center with a diagnosis of primary cutaneous invasive malignant melanoma were examined. Whether the outside pathology reports contained information on tumor thickness, level of invasion, and ulceration was recorded. Dermatopathologists had issued 76.3% of the reports and general surgical pathologists, 24.3%. Information provided was as follows: tumor thickness, 97.8%; Clark level, 71.9%; and presence or absence of ulceration, 28.1%. Of the 97 melanomas with no comment on ulceration, 17 were indeed ulcerated. Thus, the lack of a comment on ulceration cannot be equated with the absence of ulceration.
The present study documents that many pathology reports on melanomas lack sufficient information for AJCC staging. Therefore, review of outside pathology material is necessary not only to confirm or revise the tumor diagnosis but also to provide clinicians with histologic parameters required for AJCC staging.
J Natl Cancer Inst 1995;87:366-371
Increasing tumor thickness associated with expression of very late activation (VLA-4) in tumor cells increased with a concomitant decrease in VLA-6 expression
VLA-4 correlates significantly with metastases
Intratumoral vessels staining positive for ELAM-1 (E-selectin) and CD62 (P-selectin) and melanoma cells positive for VLA-4 correlated with decreased disease free survival and overall survival time
Eur J Cancer 1997;33:926
Tumors with high levesl had significantly reduced 5 YRS compared to those with low levels
Cutaneous melanoma and atypical Spitz tumors in childhood.
Barnhill RL, Flotte TJ, Fleischli M, Perez-Atayde A.
Department of Pathology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Cancer 1995 Nov 15;76(10):1833-45 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND. Malignant melanoma in childhood is rare. As a result, the biology and natural history of melanoma in this age group is still poorly understood. Although the majority of Spitz nevi are benign regardless of atypical features, a particular problem is the continued confusion of Spitz nevi with atypical features with melanoma and the lack of specific criteria for their distinction. The latter discrimination is perhaps not so difficult when Spitz nevi are minimally atypical; however, the greater the atypia, the more challenging is this discrimination.
METHODS. All cases of malignant melanoma referred to Children's Hospital (Boston, MA) and to one of the authors were examined during the period of 1959-1995. Criteria for inclusion in the study included: (1) age up to 15 years; (2) availability of microscopic slides; and (3) availability of demographic data.
RESULTS. There were 11 males and 12 females, ranging in age from 2 to 15 years (mean age, 9.4 years). Histopathologically, the 23 tumors were categorized into four subgroups: (1) small cell melanoma (5); (2) adult-like melanoma (6); (3) Spitz-like melanoma (3), and (4) atypical Spitz tumors (9). The small cell melanomas were notable for localization to the scalp, significant thickness, and fatal outcome. The adult-like melanomas resembled typical tumors occurring in adults. The one fatal Spitz-like melanoma was located on the neck of a 14-year-old male. Two tumors in this group metastasized to regional lymph nodes, but were not associated with further aggressive disease on follow-up despite treatment with surgical excision only. The atypical Spitz tumors were characterized by significant thickness and abnormal features including prominent cellularity and mitotic activity.
CONCLUSIONS. Anatomic site and cell type may be important prognostic factors in addition to tumor thickness for childhood melanoma, but these tumors require further study. In addition, the biologic potential of atypical Spitz tumors has not been characterized sufficiently.
Childhood melanoma survival.
Saenz NC, Saenz-Badillos J, Busam K, LaQuaglia MP, Corbally M, Brady MS.
Department of Surgery, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York, USA.
Cancer 1999 Feb 1;85(3):750-4 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND. Melanoma in childhood is uncommon. Some believe that melanoma among children is associated with a better prognosis than among adults.
METHODS. The authors reviewed their institutional experience with melanoma in 40 patients younger than 18 years treated between 1950 and 1984. All slides were reviewed by a single dermatopathologist who was blinded to clinical outcomes. Long term follow-up was available for all but three patients.
RESULTS. There were 26 girls and 14 boys. The median age at diagnosis was 15 years (range, 3-17 years). Eleven patients (28%) were younger than 12 years. Fifteen patients (38%) had melanoma arise in a congenital nevus (2 had bathing trunk nevi. The most common site was the extremity (n = 23), followed by the trunk (n = 10) and the head and neck (n = 7). Seventeen patients (43%) initially were considered to have benign lesions, and 23 patients (57%) were diagnosed correctly with melanoma at initial presentation. Only 21 of 37 evaluable patients (57%) were alive at last follow-up with a median follow-up of 18 years (range, 2-48 years). Fifteen patients (41%) died of their disease, with a median survival of 12 months (range, 6-60 months). One patient died of breast carcinoma 14 years after treatment for melanoma. Disease free survival was 57% at 5 and 10 years. Of the 15 patients who died of disease, 12 were female (P = 0.09) and 10 had melanoma arising in a congenital nevus (P < 0.05). Five-year overall survival was 78% for patients who presented with localized disease (n = 23) and 30% for patients who presented with regional metastasis (n = 16, P < 0.001). There were no survivors among those who presented with systemic disease (n = 1).
CONCLUSIONS. Children with melanoma are at significant risk of dying of their disease. Survival is similar to that seen among adults and depends on stage at presentation. The survival advantage observed for adult females is not seen among children.
Prepubertal malignant melanoma: report of three cases.
Strojan P, Lamovec J.
Department of Radiotherapy, Institute of Oncology, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Pediatr Hematol Oncol 2000 Mar;17(2):163-9 Abstract quote
Prepubertal malignant melanoma (MM) is an extremely rare tumor.
In Slovenia, 13 MM cases were registered between 1968 and 1996 by the Cancer Registry of Slovenia. The diagnosis of MM was confirmed by histology in 3 children. In 3 other children the lesions initially diagnosed as MM were reclassified as Spitz nevus. In the remaining cases, the slides were not accessible for histological review, and the clinical course of disease corroborated the diagnosis of a benign nevus.
In the present report, 3 of 13 cases with histologically confirmed prepubertal MM are described. The difficulties encountered in the diagnosis and management of this rare condition are discussed.
Reliability of the histopathologic diagnosis of malignant melanoma in childhood.
Wechsler J, Bastuji-Garin S, Spatz A, Bailly C, Cribier B, Andrac-Meyer L, Vergier B, Fraitag S, Verola O, Wolkenstein P.
Department of Dermatology, Henri-Mondor Hospital, F-94010 Creteil CEDEX, France.
Arch Dermatol 2002 May;138(5):625-8 Abstract quote
OBJECTIVE: To assess interrater reliability in the diagnosis of malignant melanoma in children.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: We collected 85 slides of melanomas diagnosed in patients younger than 17 years through a network of dermatopathologists and dermatologists. The slides were classified into 3 categories: (1) slides from children with metastatic melanoma; (2) slides from disease-free children with a follow-up of less than 5 years; (3) slides from disease-free children with a follow-up of 5 years or longer. Category 1 was considered the gold standard. Four pairs of expert dermatopathologists reviewed the slides and classified them into melanoma, nevus (including Spitz nevus), or ambiguous tumors.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Concordance between pairs of experts.
RESULTS: For category 1 slides (n = 20), the concordance was weak to moderate. For category 2 slides (n = 47), the concordance was weak. For category 3 slides (n = 18), the concordance was poor to moderate.
CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the reliability of diagnosis of melanoma in childhood is poor, even when submitted to experts.
Cutaneous melanoma in childhood and adolescence: An analysis of 36 patients.
Schmid-Wendtner MH, Berking C, Baumert J, Schmidt M, Sander CA, Plewig G, Volkenandt M.
Department of Dermatology and Allergology and Tumor Registry, Department of Medical Informatics, Biometry and Epidemiology, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, Munich.
J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 Jun;46(6):874-9 Abstract quote
Analysis of data of 6931 patients with cutaneous melanoma seen at the Department of Dermatology and Allergology at the Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich between 1977 and 1998 identified 36 patients in whom cutaneous melanomas developed during childhood or adolescence (age <18 years).
Clinical courses of all patients and histopathologic characteristics of the lesions were reviewed. Seventeen patients were boys and 19 patients were girls. The median ages of the boys and girls were 15 and 16 years, respectively (range, 2-17 years). Thirty-one patients presented with nonmetastatic primary melanomas and 5 patients presented with metastatic melanoma. Forty-seven percent of the primary lesions were associated with a nevus (22% with congenital nevi and 25% with acquired nevi). Tumor thickness ranged from 0.24 to 7.0 mm, with a median of 1.29 mm (mean, 1.67 mm). All patients with primary melanomas received surgical therapy; patients with metastatic disease received chemotherapy, radiation therapy, or both. Relative 5-year survival was 87.5% for the group of patients younger than 18 years. Similar to experience in adult patients, survival strongly correlated with tumor thickness and clinical stage at the time of diagnosis.
The data emphasize that a high index of suspicion for cutaneous melanoma is needed by clinicians assessing melanocytic lesions in children and adolescents for early diagnosis. Reduction of the melanoma mortality rate in children and adolescents will be achieved through identification of patients at increased risk.
Congenital and infantile melanoma: review of the literature and report of an uncommon variant, pigment-synthesizing melanoma.
Richardson SK, Tannous ZS, Mihm MC Jr.
Dermatopathology Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, 55 Fruit Street, Boston, MA 02114-2696, USA
J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 Jul;47(1):77-90 Abstract quote
Congenital and infantile types of melanoma are uncommon conditions for which there are limited epidemiologic data. The number of reported cases is small with several ascribed etiologies.
We review the literature and report the first documented case, to our knowledge, of pigment-synthesizing melanoma in an infant. Reported cases of congenital and infantile melanoma were identified and categorized on the basis of disease origin. Dermatopathologic specimens from an infant given a diagnosis of pigment-synthesizing melanoma are described. Disease arising from medium and large/giant congenital nevi was most common, whereas reports of de novo and transplacental disease were infrequent. Death of approximately 40% of patients was noted within 18 months of diagnosis. Male infants accounted for approximately 74% of cases. The most commonly affected anatomic sites were the head and neck.
The prognosis for congenital and infantile melanoma is poor. The high incidence of head-and-neck involvement and male predominance for disease suggest dispositions for both anatomic disease localization and sex.
Extra c-myc oncogene copies in high risk cutaneous malignant melanoma and melanoma metastases.
Kraehn GM, Utikal J, Udart M, Greulich KM, Bezold G, Kaskel P, Leiter U, Peter RU.
Department of Dermatology, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany.
Br J Cancer 2001 Jan 5;84(1):72-9 Abstract quote
Amplification and overexpression of the c-myc gene have been associated with neoplastic transformation in a plethora of malignant tumours.
We applied interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with a locus-specific probe for the c-myc gene (8q24) in combination with a corresponding chromosome 8 alpha-satellite probe to evaluate genetic alterations in 8 primary melanomas and 33 advanced melanomas and compared it to 12 melanocytic nevi, 7 safety margins and 2 cases of normal skin. Additionally, in metaphase spreads of 7 melanoma cell lines a whole chromosome 8 paint probe was used.
We investigated the functionality of the c-myc gene by detecting c-myc RNA expression with RT-PCR and c-myc protein by immunohistochemistry. 4/8 primary melanomas and 11/33 melanoma metastases showed additional c-myc signals relative to the centromere of chromosome 8 copy number. None of the nevi, safety margins or normal skin samples demonstrated this gain. In 2/7 melanoma cell lines (C32 and WM 266-4) isochromosome 8q formation with a relative gain of c-myc copies and a loss of 8p was observed. The highest c-myc gene expression compared to GAPDH was found in melanoma metastases (17.5%). Nevi (6.6%) and primary melanomas (5.0%) expressed the c-myc gene on a lower level. 72.7% of the patients with c-myc extra copies had visceral melanoma metastases (UICC IV), patients without c-myc gain in 35.0% only. The collective with additional c-myc copies also expressed the gene on a significantly higher level.
These results indicate that a c-myc gain in relation to the centromere 8 copy number might be associated with advanced cutaneous melanoma.
Mitotic cyclins and cyclin-dependent kinases in melanocytic lesions.
Tran TA, Ross JS, Carlson JA, Mihm MC Jr.
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Albany Medical College and Samuel S. Stratton Veterans Administration Medical Center, NY 12208, USA.
Hum Pathol 1998 Oct;29(10):1085-90 Abstract quote
Recent evidence has implicated cyclins and cyclin-dependent kinases in the evolution and progression of various malignancies.
We studied the immunohistochemical expression of cyclin A, cyclin B, and cyclin-dependent kinase p34cdc2 in a broad spectrum of benign and malignant melanocytic lesions. Formalin-embedded, parrafin-fixed tissue sections from 66 malignant melanomas (MM) and 60 benign nevi were examined for the expression of these cell-cycle proteins. The results were compared with the standard proliferative marker Ki-67 and mitotic index. MM showed significantly higher immunoreactivity for cyclin A, cyclin B, p34cdc2, and Ki-67 compared with benign nevi. Cyclin A, p34cdc2, and Ki-67 displayed strong co-expression in MM. Overexpression of cyclin A and p34cdc2 correlated with histological type, mitotic activity, Ki-67 index, tumor thickness, Clark's level, and clinical outcome in MM.
In invasive MM, increased immunostaining of cyclin A and Ki-67 were associated with decreased patient survival. These findings indicate potential roles of mitotic cyclins and cyclin-dependent kinases in the pathogenesis and progression of malignant melanoma.
Relationship of tumorigenic malignant melanomas to dermal elastin: an expression of tumor/stromal interaction that may be related to prognosis.
Feinmesser M, Schachter JM, Tobar A, Sulkes J, Gutman H, Kruk N, Okon E.
Department of Pathology, Rabin Medical Center, Beilinson Campus, Petah Tiqva, Israel.
Am J Dermatopathol 2002 Apr;24(2):108-17 Abstract quote
Malignant melanomas, which produce a large number of substances active in connective tissue modulation, must contend with the dermis to grow and propagate.
We studied the morphologic interactions between tumorigenic malignant melanomas and dermal elastin. Formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded tissues of 108 tumorigenic malignant melanomas were stained for elastic tissue with the Verhoeff-van Gieson method. Various aspects of the relationship between malignant melanoma and dermal elastin were analyzed in relation to the histologic and clinical data using univariate and multivariate analyses. Tumor thickness, mitotic rate, and the presence of elastin remnants within the tumors were found to be independent negative prognostic factors, the latter with borderline significance.
Tumors with more remnants of elastin were associated with higher stage of disease and lymph node and distant metastases. Tumor infiltration between the elastic fibers in the tumor depth was associated with high Clark level, greater tumor thickness, high stage of disease, and lymph node metastases. At least partial preservation of elastic fibers in the tumor depth was a relatively good prognostic factor whereas complete absence of elastin was an adverse factor. Focal or multifocal absence of elastin in the midst of the tumors or in their depth was usually associated with lymphocytic infiltrates.
We suggest that tumors with remnants of elastic fibers and/or invasion between elastic fibers in their depth may be fast growing and highly invasive. The absence of elastin within tumors and at their advancing edge may be related to the elaboration of elastin-degrading substances by melanoma cells or various inflammatory cells. Our findings indicate that the relationship between malignant melanomas and dermal connective tissue components, specifically elastin, may have prognostic significance.
Epithelioid cell melanomas have greater DNA ploidy abnormalities than spindle cell melanomas: cytological evidence for a higher malignant potential of the former.
Chi HI, Uyeda Y, Umebayashi Y, Otsuka F.
Department of Dermatology, Tokyo Hitachi Hospital, Japan.
Arch Dermatol Res 1993;285(7):410-4 Abstract quote
The cellular DNA ploidy of 30 cases of malignant melanoma was measured by 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole-DNA (DAPI-DNA) microfluorometry.
DNA histograms and DNA index values were compared among melanomas of different cell morphology. Epithelioid cell melanomas often showed greater DNA aneuploidy than spindle cell melanomas in terms of histographic pattern. DNA index values of the former (mean +/- standard error, 1.84 +/- 0.31) were significantly higher than those of the latter (1.55 +/- 0.24; P < 0.05). The DNA index values of mixed-type melanomas were intermediate. These results indicate that the epithelioid cell melanomas have greater DNA ploidy abnormalities which are usually correlated with a greater malignant potential in pigmentary neoplasms.
Thus our results confirm clinical evidence that melanoma patients with the epithelioid type of cells have a poorer prognosis than those with the spindle type of cells.
Does biopsy type influence survival in clinical stage I cutaneous melanoma?
Lederman JS, Sober AJ.
J Am Acad Dermatol 1985 Dec;13(6):983-7 Abstract quote
A total of 472 patients with clinical Stage I cutaneous melanoma were analyzed to determine influence of type of diagnostic biopsy on survival. Of these patients, 119 had had an incisional biopsy (either punch or incision) and 353 had an excisional biopsy. Patients were grouped by thickness category and outcome compared between the biopsy types.
Within each thickness category, there is no statistically significant difference in survival between the two groups. The observation that none of the seventy-six patients with primary tumors less than 1.70 mm have died following incisional biopsy strongly argues against any deleterious effect of incisional biopsy in this group. Alternatively, if the two highest-risk groups (greater than or equal to 1.70 mm) are analyzed as a single group, an adverse effect is seen in the incisional biopsy group (p less than 0.05). However, when the data from these groups are subjected to multivariate analysis, biopsy type is not a significant factor in the model.
This study shows that either biopsy method may be used in first evaluating patients with suspected melanoma.
Does wide excision as the initial diagnostic procedure improve prognosis in patients with cutaneous melanoma?
Lederman JS, Sober AJ.
J Dermatol Surg Oncol 1986 Jul;12(7):697-9 Abstract quote
502 patients with clinical stage I cutaneous melanoma were reviewed to determine if performing a wide excision (4-5 cm) at the time when the diagnosis of melanoma is suspected, improves the survival.
Patients were divided into two groups based on initial biopsy type and thickness category. Group 1, wide excision; group 2, total excision with narrow margins, incisional, or punch biopsies. There was no evidence that patients who had had a diagnostic and therapeutic procedure (wide excision) as the initial approach had a better survival than those who had had another form of biopsy before definitive surgery.
We cannot recommend excision with wide margins as the initial biopsy procedure for a lesion suspected to be melanoma before histologic verification, since it does not increase survival for melanoma and may result in unnecessary aggressive surgery in the case of a misdiagnosed benign lesion.
Effect of initial biopsy procedure on prognosis in Stage 1 invasive cutaneous malignant melanoma: review of 1086 patients.
Lees VC, Briggs JC.
Department of Plastic Surgery, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK.
Br J Surg 1991 Sep;78(9):1108-10 Abstract quote
After treatment for primary clinical Stage 1 invasive cutaneous malignant melanoma, 1086 patients were followed for a minimum of 5 years from initial operation. Patient data were retrieved from the unit's melanoma registry; 96 (8.8 per cent) were treated initially by incisional biopsy, 292 (26.9 per cent) by narrow margin excision biopsy and 698 (64.3 per cent) by wide margin excision.
Logistic regression analysis was performed to assess the statistical significance of the association between the various factors. The method of initial biopsy was related to maximal tumour thickness, age, and sex.
Incisional biopsy rendered 38 out of 96 (40 per cent) lesions not fully assessable on current histopathological criteria, significantly higher than for the other biopsy techniques (P less than 0.0001). Incisional biopsy did not adversely affect prognosis in terms of local recurrence and mortality. Prognosis was related to tumour thickness, age and sex of the patient, and not to biopsy technique.
We recommend that all suspicious lesions should be submitted to excisional rather than incisional biopsy to avoid compromising the histological assessment, given the importance of maximal tumour thickness in determining treatment and prognosis.
Influence of biopsy on the prognosis of cutaneous melanoma of the head and neck.
Austin JR, Byers RM, Brown WD, Wolf P.
Department of Head and Neck Surgery, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, USA.
Head Neck 1996 Mar-Apr;18(2):107-17 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND: This study was performed to determine the effect of biopsy type on survival rates and on local, regional, and distant metastasis in patients with head and neck cutaneous melanoma.
METHODS: A case series of 159 patients with melanoma of the head and neck referred to a tertiary-care center between 1983 and 1991, with a median follow-up of 38 months, was reviewed. Information analyzed included patient's age, sex, type of treatment, mode of biopsy, presence of residual melanoma in reexcision, location of lesion, presence of ulceration, Clark's level, Breslow thickness, and histologic type of the melanoma.
RESULTS: Excisional biopsy was performed in 79 patients, incisional biopsy in 48, and other procedures (shave, needle biopsy, cauterization, or cryotherapy) in 32. There were no significant pretreatment differences among the three groups in sex, thickness, histologic type, presence of nodal disease, or type of treatment. Pretreatment location of lesion was significantly different (p = .03) between the excisional and other biopsy types. Association between type of biopsy and survival rate was significant (p<.001):31.3% of patients in the incisional biopsy group died of disease, as did 25% of the other biopsy group, versus 8.9% of the excisional biopsy group; 31.3% of patients in the incisional biopsy group developed distant metastases, as did 28.1% of the other biopsy type, versus 10.1% of those in the excisional biopsy group (p = .01). There was no significant difference in local p = .37) or regional (p = 1.00) recurrence among the three biopsy groups. Multivariate analysis showed presence of tumor in the re-excision specimen, biopsy type, and nodal disease to be independent prognostic factors.
CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that the type of biopsy of cutaneous melanoma of the head and neck may influence the clinical outcome.
Incisional biopsy and melanoma prognosis.
Bong JL, Herd RM, Hunter JA.
Departments of Dermatology, Western Infirmary, Glasgow, and The Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh.
J Am Acad Dermatol 2002 May;46(5 Pt 1):690-4 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND: There are many circumstances in clinical practice in which it is helpful to have a definitive diagnosis of melanoma before subjecting a patient to mutilating surgery. Previous studies on the effect of incisional biopsy on melanoma prognosis were conflicting and lacked a matched control group to account for the other prognostic indicators.
OBJECTIVE: We set up this study to investigate the effect of incisional biopsy on melanoma prognosis.
METHODS: The design was of a retrospective case control. Data were obtained from the database of the Scottish Melanoma Group; the database was set up in 1979 to collect detailed clinical, pathologic, and follow-up data on all patients diagnosed with melanoma in Scotland. Each incisional case was matched against 2 excision cases controlling for age, sex, sites, and Breslow thickness. The main outcome measures were time from initial biopsy to recurrence and to melanoma-related death.
RESULTS: Two hundred sixty-five patients who had incisional biopsy before definitive excision of melanoma were included in the study; these were matched with 496 cases of excisional biopsy specimens. Cox's proportional hazard model for survival analysis showed that biopsy type had no significant effect on recurrence (P =.30) or melanoma-related death (P =.34).
CONCLUSIONS: This study is the largest series on the effect of incisional biopsy on melanoma prognosis to date and the first to include matched controls. Melanoma prognosis is not influenced by incisional biopsy,. before definitive excision.
J Cutan Pathol 1991;18:264-72.
J Cutan Pathol 1992;19:110-5.
J Invest Dermatol 1995;105:22-6.
J Am Acad Dermatol 1996;35:416-8.
Concurrent Ki-67 and p53 immunolabeling in cutaneous melanocytic neoplasms: an adjunct for recognition of the vertical growth phase in malignant melanomas?
Kaleem Z, Lind AC, Humphrey PA, Sueper RH, Swanson PE, Ritter JH, Wick MR. Lauren V.
Ackerman Laboratory of Surgical Pathology, Washington University Medical Center, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
Mod Pathol 2000 Mar;13(3):217-22 Abstract quote
Ki-67 labeling of paraffin sections has been correlated with the number of cells in non-G(o) phases of the replicative cell cycle, and this immunohistochemical technique has been applied to the evaluation of a variety of human neoplasms. Similarly, immunolabeling for p53 protein has been used to detect mutations in the corresponding gene, as a reflection of possible cellular transformation in the same context.
Both of these techniques were applied to 253 melanocytic tumors of the skin to assess their possible utility in the diagnosis and subcategorization of such lesions. They included 76 banal (common) nevi (CN), 39 Spitz nevi (SN), 62 superficial spreading malignant melanomas in radial growth (SSMMs), 32 nodular malignant melanomas (NMMs), 21 lentigo maligna melanomas in radial growth (LMMs), and 23 melanomas arising in association with preexisting compound nevi (MCN). One hundred cells were counted randomly in each tumor, and dark, exclusively nuclear reactivity was scored as positive labeling; results were recorded as percentages.
Negligible Ki-67 and p53 labeling was seen in CN and SN, at a level that was similar to that obtained in cases of LMM and MCN. T
he largest proportion of Ki-67-positive and p53-positive cells was observed in NMMs, followed by SSMMs. Radial growth-phase SSMMs and LMMs demonstrated immunoprofiles that were similar to those of melanocytic nevi, and MCN did so as well.
The prototypical malignant melanocytic tumor representing the vertical growth phase-nodular melanoma--demonstrated a statistically significant difference from all other lesions in this study with respect to Ki-67 index (P = .008, chi2) and p53 reactivity (P < .000001, chi2). Subsequent concurrent use of a Ki-67 threshold index of 10% and a p53 index of 5% correctly indicated the presence of vertical growth in 75% of NMMs, whereas only 8% of radial growth phase melanomas of other types were colabeled at the same levels of reactivity for the two markers (P < .00001, chi2).
Thus, although the distinction between benign and malignant melanocytic tumors could and should not be based on immunohistology for Ki-67 and p53, these results suggest that the latter determinants may, in fact, be used as an adjunct to morphology in the recognition of the vertical growth phase in cutaneous malignant melanomas.
J Am Acad Dermatol 2001;44:188-92
Ki-67 reactivity in primary melanomas was evaluated as at least 5% of positive neoplastic cells and was assessed on fresh specimens of 55 primary lesions at the time of excision
At least 4 fields of approximately 100 tumor cells each per slide were counted at 40× magnification. The number of Ki-67-reactive cells in each field was determined as a percentage of the total number of tumor cells counted. A mean percentage of Ki-67 immunoreactive melanoma cells was calculated for each lesion. The percentage of positive cells per lesion was scored according to 3 different categories: zero to 4%, 5% to 10%, 11% to 30%. A cut-off point of 5% stained cells was chosen to identify positive lesions.
Reactivity was correlated with metastatic relapse of patients in a prospective study, by means of multivariate Cox regression models (follow-up, 3-120 months)
Ki-67 immunoreactivity was associated with increasing thickness (P = .003)
Positive correlation was found between Ki-67 reactivity and metastatic dissemination in primary melanomas less than 1.5 mm thick (n = 23; mean thickness, 0.75 ± 0.3 mm; P = .002)
A negative correlation was found between Ki-67 reactivity and metastatic activity in primary melanomas thicker than 1.5 mm (n = 32; mean thickness, 4.0 ± 1.6 mm; P = .019).
Ki-67 proliferative activity appears to be a possible predictor of metastasis in primary melanomas, in particular, an indicator of poor prognosis in lesions less than 1.5 mm thick.
Am J Dermatopathol 2001;22:489-495
Average number and maximal number (%) of MIB-1 positive nuclei were determined in superficial, middle, and deep dermal zones as well as the entire lesion
23 compound nevi
17 dysplastic nevi
8 Spitz nevi
24 malignant melanomas
Utilizing the % MIB-1 mean and max from whole lesions had better discriminating abilities than individual zones
Using the % Mean from all zones, all lesions except one Spitz nevus and 3 melanomsa could be correctly classified as benign or malignant
Using the % MIB-1-max from all zones, all lesions but 2 Spitz nevi could be correctly classified
A zonal comparison of MIB1-Ki67 immunoreactivity in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions.
Li LX, Crotty KA, McCarthy SW, Palmer AA, Kril JJ.
Department of Pathology, University of Sydney, and Centre for Education and Research on Ageing, Concord Hospital, New South Wales, Australia.
Am J Dermatopathol 2000 Dec;22(6):489-95 Abstract quote
Differentiation between malignant melanomas and benign nevi can sometimes be difficult by conventional histopathology, and additional diagnostic markers may be helpful.
This study investigated the immunoreactivity of the cell proliferation marker MIB1-Ki67 in 23 compound nevi, 17 dysplastic nevi, 8 Spitz nevi (SN), and 24 malignant melanomas (MMs) and evaluated its ability in separating benign nevi from MMs.
In each lesion, the average number (percentage) of MIB1-positive nuclei (%MIB1-Mean) and the maximal number (percentage) of MIB1-positive nuclei (%MIB1-Max) were determined from each of the superficial, middle, and deep dermal zones of the lesion as well as from the entire lesion. The %MIB1-Max was determined from subjectively selected area(s) of high count. Malignant melanomas had a significantly greater %MIB1-Mean and %MIB1-Max than all benign nevi in all individual zones and in the entire lesion (p < 0.05). Discriminant analysis showed that the %MIB1-Mean and %MIB1-Max counted from the whole lesions had better discriminating abilities than from the individual zones. By using the %MIB1-Mean from all zones, all lesions except 1 SN and 3 MMs could be correctly classified as benign or malignant. When using the %MIB1-Max from all zones, all but 2 SN could be correctly separated as benign or malignant.
Thus, MIB1-Ki67 immunoreactivity closely correlates with the benignancy or malignancy of melanocytic lesions and may assist in the differentiation of benign nevi from MMs.
MIB-1 monoclonal antibody to determine proliferative activity of Ki-67 antigen as an adjunct to the histopathologic differential diagnosis of Spitz nevi
J Am Acad Dermatol 2001;44:500-4 Abstract quote
Twenty-five compound SNs, 27 MMs, and 26 compound nondysplastic melanocytic nevi (MNs) were immunostained with the MIB-1 antibody.
Results: The mean counts of MIB-1-stained tumor cells of the epidermal and dermal components, both alone and together, were significantly lower in SNs and MNs than in MMs (P < .0001). The dermal counts showed the best discriminating power. In addition, the mean dermal/epidermal count ratios for MIB-1 in SNs and MNs (0.25 and 0.23, respectively) were significantly lower than the corresponding ratio (0.94) in MMs (P < .0001).
Conclusion: MIB-1-stained tumor cell counts, especially of the dermal component, and dermal/epidermal MIB-1 count ratios may be helpful as an adjunct to the histopathologic differential diagnosis of SN.
Cutaneous malignant melanoma: correlation between neovascularization and peritumor accumulation of mast cells overexpressing vascular endothelial growth factor.
Toth-Jakatics R, Jimi S, Takebayashi S, Kawamoto N.
Second Department of Pathology, Fukuoka University, School of Medicine, Japan.
Hum Pathol 2000 Aug;31(8):955-60 Abstract quote
To investigate the possible role of mast cells (MC) in the angiogenic process in cutaneous melanoma, we examined tissue samples from 35 adult patients with primary malignant melanoma and compared with 20 intradermal benign nevi.
MC were identified by anti-tryptase, microvessels by anti-CD34, and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) expression by standard immunohistochemical methods. Tryptase-positive MC expressing VEGF were identified by double immunostaining. The numbers of MC and microvessels around the tumor were determined by the point counting method. MC density was significantly greater in melanoma compared with benign nevi (197.6 +/- 19.4 v 95.7 +/- 5.0/mm2, P < .001). Vascular density was also significantly higher in melanoma than in benign lesions (3.6-fold, P < .001). Double immunostaining showed the presence of VEGF in the cytoplasm of tryptase-positive peritumoral MC. The percentage of this MC-subtype was significantly higher in melanoma than in nevus tissues (71.9 +/- 2.4% v 30.6 +/- 2.5%, P < .001). A strong significant correlation was shown between the number of VEGF+ MC and microvessel density (r = .811, P < .001). MC count and VEGF+ MC count, as well as microvessel density were significantly higher in aggressive (metastasizing) melanomas (P < .001).
Our results suggest that peritumoral accumulation of MC and the subsequent release of potent angiogenic factor such as VEGF may thus represent a tumor-host interaction that may favor progression of this tumor.
Am J Dermatopathol 2001;23:29-35
Tumors of 44 patients
25/44 positive (nuclear and/or cytoplasmic staining positivity)
37.5% of level I-III positive
80% of level IV-V positive
Strong correlation between expression and level of invasion and tumor thickness
Survival distribution function curve (Kaplan-Meier) had a better survival rate for negative group
Hum Pathol 2000;31:1346-1356
Inverse correlation with metastatic potential in human and murine cell lines, this study examined archived specimens
Study utilized in situ hybridization with S35 labeled probes, mRNA expression was analyzed in 64 cases of normal skin, benign melanocytic nevi, primary cutaneous melanoma, and melanoma metastases
Ubiquitous expression was observed in all benign nevi (14/14) with some nevi showing a gradient of reduced expression with increased dermal depth
Uniform expression in 49% of primary cutaneous melanoma (18/37)
Loss of expression in 53% (19/36) of invasive melanoma
Loss of expression in 100% of melanoma metastases (11/11)
Focal aggregate or nodule of melanoma cells without detectable signal was the most commonly observed pattern in melastatin loss of expression
Melanoma growth stimulatory activity in primary malignant melanoma: prognostic significance.
Middleman BR, Friedman M, Lawson DH, DeRose PB, Cohen C.
Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Mod Pathol 2002 May;15(5):532-7 Abstract quote
Malignant melanoma (MM) cells do not require all exogenous growth factors of normal melanocytes. It is hypothesized that they make their own growth factors including melanoma growth stimulatory activity (MGSA). Cultured melanoma cells respond to MGSA with increased growth and angiogenesis suggesting a role for MGSA in MM proliferation, differentiation, and progression.
We assessed the prognostic significance of MGSA expression in 37 primary MM immunostained for MGSA. Immunostains were graded for intensity (0-3+), percentage of cells immunostained, and location of immunostain (intraepidermal, junctional, or dermal). In addition, 31 melanocytic and 23 dysplastic nevi were similarly studied for MGSA expression. All MM showed the presence of immunostain, 6 (16%) 1+, 12 (32%) 2+, and 19 (51%) 3+. Six (16%) had immunostain in </=50% tumor cells, 31 (84%) in >50%. A significant number of MM showed >50% tumor cells staining at the dermal-epidermal junction compared with intraepidermal staining (P <.0001). Intensity and amount of immunostain did not correlate with Clark's or Breslow's level. During a mean follow-up of 60 months (range: 5-101) on 27 patients, there were 4 local recurrences, 6 distant metastases, and 10 deaths. MGSA expression was not of prognostic significance with regard to survival (overall, disease free), or local recurrence or distant metastasis in primary MM. MGSA expression was similar in benign melanocytic and dysplastic nevi. Strong diffuse expression was noted in the junctional component of all junctional and most compound nevi.
The dermal component consistently expressed less or no (in 45% of intradermal nevi) MGSA. MGSA expression does not correlate with prognosis in MM. Increased expression of MGSA at the dermal-epidermal junction in nevi and MM may indicate a role for MGSA in early local growth, before development of atypia.
Expression of polo-like kinase (PLK1) in thin melanomas: a novel marker of metastatic disease.
Kneisel L, Strebhardt K, Bernd A, Wolter M, Binder A, Kaufmann R.
Department of Dermatology Johann Wolfgang Goethe-University, School of Medicine, Frankfurt, Germany Department of Gynaecology, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-University, School of Medicine, Frankfurt, Germany.
J Cutan Pathol 2002 Jul;29(6):354-8 Abstract quote
Background: The maximum thickness of a primary malignant melanoma as measured by Breslow's method is currently the most important prognostic factor. However, some thin melanomas (</= 0.75 mm), which should have an excellent prognosis according to Breslow, can be lethal due to their ability to metastasize.
Methods: In our study, thin malignant melanomas (</= 0.75 mm) from 36 patients were analyzed with immunohistochemical techniques using monoclonal antibodies directed against PLK1 and Ki-67. The immunoreactivity of 22 melanomas which developed metastases within 5 years of follow-up was compared with a group of 14 non-metastasized melanomas. Two independent investigators evaluated stained sections. Differences of PLK1 and Ki-67 indices between melanomas with and without metastases were tested statistically using the Mann-Whitney U-test.
Results: Malignant melanomas with metastases expressed PLK1 at markedly elevated levels compared to melanomas without metastases (median, 60.00% vs. 37.98%; p = 0.000053). The difference of the Ki-67 index between both groups was not significant (median, 6.35% vs. 4.53%; p = 0.150473).
Conclusions: Our results suggest that PLK1 expression in thin melanomas is a reliable marker to identify patients at high risk for metastases.
Arch Surg 1983;118:41-44
Ann Surg 1988;208:150-161
Virchows Arch 1985;406:179-195
Controversial whether regression is associated with a worse prognosis and risk of metastases
This study found regressive change in 12.3% of 437 primary melanomas with less than 10% of patients reporting regression of a pigmented lesion
Arch Dermatol 1987;123:1326-1330
Most ominous study found that patients with thin melanomas with regression in greater than 75% of the lesion, metastases are prone to occur
Lichenoid Tissue Reaction in Malignant Melanoma
A Potential Diagnostic Pitfall
CPT Scott R. Dalton, MC, USA,1,3 Capt Matt A. Baptista, USAF, MC,1,3 COL Lester F. Libow, MC, USA,2 and COL Dirk M. Elston, MC, USA2
Am J Clin Pathol 2002;117:766-770 Abstract quote
Lichenoid tissue reactions can occur in malignant melanoma and may cause partial regression of the lesion. We studied a series of melanomas to determine how frequently lichenoid tissue reaction obscures the diagnosis of malignant melanoma.
We retrospectively reviewed 342 cases of invasive malignant melanoma and melanoma in situ from the head, neck, chest, and back. Of the 342 cases, 23 (6.7%) had a lichenoid tissue reaction obscuring a portion of the lesion. In 6 cases (1.8%), the lichenoid tissue reaction replaced a major portion of the lesion.
Knowledge of this phenomenon can prevent misdiagnosis.
Small melanomas: a clinical study on 270 consecutive cases of cutaneous melanoma.
Bono A, Bartoli C, Moglia D, Maurichi A, Camerini T, Grassi G, Tragni G, Cascinelli N.
Unit for Cutaneous Oncology, Istituto Nazionale Tumori, Milan, Italy.
Melanoma Res 1999 Dec;9(6):583-6 Abstract quote
The ABCD (asymmetry, border, colour, dimension) criteria represent a commonly used clinical guide for the diagnosis of early cutaneous melanoma (CM). This guide stipulates that CMs usually are more than 6 mm in diameter.
The purpose of this retrospective study was to establish the frequency of occurrence of small (< or =6 mm) melanomas in a clinical context. Our series consisted of 270 consecutive CMs (39 in situ and 231 invasive) in 267 patients. Of these 270 lesions, 47 (17%) were small lesions, ranging from 2 to 6 mm in maximum linear extent, with a median value of 5 mm. Of these small lesions, 14 were in situ and 33 Invasive CMs. The median thickness of the 33 small invasive lesions was 0.31 mm.
The clinical features of CMs were sufficiently distinctive to suggest a diagnosis of CM in half of the cases, irrespective of the invasiveness or not of the lesions. Dermatoscopy was performed on 36 of the small lesions and achieved a correct diagnosis in 72% of the cases. The combination of simple visual examination with dermatoscopy allowed a higher rate of recognition (86%) than when the two methods were considered separately.
Results of our study show that small CMs represent a considerable clinical subset of all CMs. Clinicians must be aware of this fact in their diagnostic activity.
SOLITARY MELANOMA CONFINED TO DERMIS OR FAT Solitary melanoma confined to the dermal and/or subcutaneous tissue
Arch Dermatol 2000;136:1397-1399
By the current AJCC staging classification, these tumors are considered Stage IV disease, that is a metastatic melanoma with an unknown primary.
11/1800 patients were identified (0.61%) with a single focus of presumed metastatic disease
Kaplan-Meier 8 year survival curve was 83%
Suggesting that these presumed metastatic tumors do not behave like stage IV metastatic disease to the skin but instead behave as primary tumors
Prognostic factors in patients with thick cutaneous melanoma (> 4 mm).
Zettersten E, Sagebiel RW, Miller JR 3rd, Tallapureddy S, Leong SP, Kashani-Sabet M.
Melanoma Center, Cutaneous Oncology Program, University of California at San Francisco, Comprehensive Cancer Center, San Francisco, California 94115, USA.
Cancer 2002 Feb 15;94(4):1049-56 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND: The current study was conducted to examine the role of multiple clinical and histologic factors in the prognostic assessment of patients with thick primary melanoma (> 4 mm, classified as T4).
METHODS: A retrospective analysis was performed in 329 patients with T4 cutaneous melanomas who were seen at the University of California at San Francisco Melanoma Center between 1978 and 2000. Fourteen histopathologic features were recorded prospectively by a single dermatopathologist. In addition, 9 clinical factors were analyzed.
RESULTS: Several histologic factors were found to have a significant impact on the survival of patients with T4 melanoma. On univariate analysis, tumor thickness, ulceration, mitotic rate, microsatellites, vascular involvement, and histogenetic type of the primary tumor all were found to have a significant impact on the overall survival rate. Regional lymph node involvement reduced the overall survival of T4 patients dramatically. The 5-year overall survival of patients with lymph node-negative T4 disease was 61%, compared with 30% for those with lymph node-positive disease. When lymph node status was taken into account, tumor thickness, vascular involvement, and ulceration all remained independent predictors of overall survival on multivariate Cox regression analysis. Neither age, gender, nor anatomic location appeared to affect the recurrence-free or overall survival rates.
CONCLUSIONS: Patients with thick primary cutaneous melanomas (> 4 mm) comprise a heterogeneous group. The presence or absence of lymph node involvement, vascular involvement, and ulceration appears to result in significantly divergent overall survival rates in this patient cohort. Consideration of these factors has important implications in the management of patients with T4 melanoma.
Nodular type and older age as the most significant associations of thick melanoma in victoria, australia.
Chamberlain AJ, Fritschi L, Giles GG, Dowling JP, Kelly JW.
Department of Dermatology, Churchill Hospital, Oxford Radcliffe NHS Trust, Old Road, Headington, Oxford OX3 7LJ, England.
Arch Dermatol 2002 May;138(5):609-14 Abstract quote
OBJECTIVES: To explore the clinical associations of thick melanoma and to compare the clinicopathological variables of nodular and superficial spreading types. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study of all invasive primary melanomas recorded by the Victorian Cancer Registry for 1998 and those reviewed by the Victorian Melanoma Service between October 1, 1994, and April 31, 1999.
SETTING: Population-based cancer registry and public hospital-based multidisciplinary melanoma clinic.
PATIENTS: This study included 1422 patients recorded by the Victorian Cancer Registry and 674 patients who had attended the Victorian Melanoma Service; unclassifiable tumor types were excluded, leaving 1144 and 645 patients, respectively, eligible for analysis.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Melanomas were categorized by thickness into thin (</=1 mm), intermediate (>1-3 mm), and thick (>3 mm) and compared according to patient age, sex, and tumor type and site. Superficial spreading and nodular types were also compared in this manner. Use of the Victorian Melanoma Service database enabled a more comprehensive analysis of historical and phenotypic characteristics.
RESULTS: Thick melanoma was predominantly nodular, occurring in older men, mostly on the head and neck and associated with fewer nevi. Nodular melanoma was thicker and found mostly on the lower limbs or head and neck; it had a greater association with a history of solar keratoses than did superficial spreading melanoma.
CONCLUSION: Nodular type and older age are the most significant associations of thick melanoma.
Clin Lab Med 2000;20:713-729
Controversial term but most have taken it to refer to melanomas less than 1 mm thick although this measurement has ranged from 0.7mm to 1.5mm
If <1mm is used (as recommended by the NIH Consensus Development Conference of 1992), patients have >90% chance of long term survival
Follow-up of patients with a thin melanoma.
Johnson RC, Fenn NJ, Horgan K, Mansel RE.
Department of Surgery, University of Wales College of Medicine, Cardiff, UK.
Br J Surg 1999 May;86(5):619-21 Abstract quote
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to determine the value of follow-up in two subgroups of patients with a thin melanoma less than 0.76 mm and 0.76-1.5 mm thick.
METHODS: The study group comprised all patients presenting to the Cardiff Melanoma Clinic from its introduction in 1976 to the end of 1994. All patients attend follow-up according to a strict protocol, determined by the thickness of the original melanoma (less than 0.76 mm, annually; more than 0.76 mm, every 2 months for 2 years, 3 monthly for 2 years, 4 monthly for 1 year and then annually).
RESULTS: In total there were 306 patients with a thin melanoma: 178 with a melanoma thinner than 0.76 mm (group 1) and 128 with a melanoma of 0.76-1.5 mm (group 2). The groups were well matched for age (mean 50.6 (range 8-87) versus 50.6 (range 19-89) years respectively) and length of follow-up (mean 88.6 (range 4-296) versus 80.4 (range 2-296) months). Four patients (2.2 per cent) developed recurrence in group 1 and 16 (12.5 per cent) in group 2. The mean time to recurrence was 84.5 (range 49-143) months in group 1 and 45.3 (range 2-74) months in group 2. All patients in group 1 and 14 of 16 in group 2 died from recurrent disease.
CONCLUSION: Follow-up of patients with a melanoma less than 0.76 mm thick is not worthwhile. All recurrences would have been detected by annual review for 7 years in patients with melanomas between 0.76 and 1.5 mm thick.
High proliferative activity may predict early metastasis of thin melanomas
Sven-Olaf Frahm, MD
Christoph Schubert, MD, PhD
Reza Parwaresch, MD, PhD
Pierre Rudolph, MD, PhD
Hum Pathol 2002;32:1376-1381. Abstract quote
Metastasis of thin melanomas is uncommon and unpredictable.
We prospectively investigated the clinical course of 167 thin melanomas (<1 mm thickness) over a median observation period of 4 years (18 to 87 months). In addition to Breslow thickness, Clark level, and growth phase characteristics, we assessed cellular proliferation by counting mitoses and immunohistochemically using the monoclonal antibody Ki-S5 (Ki-67).
Mitotic and Ki-S5 indices were correlated to tumor thickness, Clarks level, and radial/vertical growth phase (RGP/VGP). However, 5 tumors had proliferation indices above 25% (outside the range of a theoretical normal distribution). Four of these tumors metastasized, and none of the melanomas with lower proliferative activity progressed during the observation period. The metastatic behavior was independent of tumor thickness and Clark level and did not unconditionally coincide with VGP or high mitotic counts.
It is concluded that the immunohistochemical proliferation index may be a powerful predictor of early systemic progression in thin melanomas, which may be helpful in making therapeutic decisions. Further investigations are needed to determine the value of proliferation measurements for the long-term prognosis of thin melanomas.
Histological characteristics of metastasizing thin melanomas: a case-control study of 43 cases.
Guitart J, Lowe L, Piepkorn M, Prieto VG, Rabkin MS, Ronan SG, Shea CR, Tron VA, White W, Barnhill RL.
Department of Dermatology, Northwestern University Medical School, 675 N St Clair, Suite 19-150, Chicago, IL 60611
Arch Dermatol 2002 May;138(5):603-8 Abstract quote
OBJECTIVE: To study clinical and histological features associated with metastasizing thin melanomas (MTMs).
DESIGN: Case-control study of clinicopathological features of patients with MTMs by a panel of 10 dermatopathologists.
SETTING: Members of the North American Melanoma Pathology Study Group selected the cases from the melanoma databases at 8 academic institutions.
PATIENTS: Forty-three patients with MTMs (<1 mm thick) and 42 control subjects without metastasis matched for age, sex, tumor site, and Breslow thickness.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Clinical (age, sex, site of lesion, stage at diagnosis, metastasis site, disease-free survival, and outcome) and histological (Breslow thickness, Clark level, growth phase, regression, and inflammatory response) features of patients with MTMs vs controls.
RESULTS: There was an overrepresentation of axial tumors among patients with MTMs. Extensive regression was present in 18 patients (42%) with MTM vs 2 matched control subjects (5%) (95% confidence interval, 21%-53%; P =.001). Other histological variables were not significantly different. Two patients had melanomas in situ with subsequent metastasis.
CONCLUSIONS: Thin melanomas with extensive regression represent a group at higher risk for the development of metastasis. Furthermore, the risk of metastasis cannot be dismissed in cases of melanoma in situ.
TUMOR INFILTRATING LYMPHOCYTES
Histologic Classification of Tumor-Infiltrating Lymphocytes in Primary Cutaneous Malignant Melanoma A Study of Interobserver Agreement
Klaus J. Busam, MD, Cristina R. Antonescu, MD, Ashfaq A. Marghoob, MD, Kishwer S. Nehal, MD, Dana L. Sachs, MD, Jinru Shia, MD, and Marianne Berwick, PhD
Am J Clin Pathol 2001;115:856-860 Abstract quote
The density and distribution of lymphocytes infiltrating the vertical growth phase of primary cutaneous melanomas has been suggested by several studies to be of prognostic significance. However, few pathologists comment on tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs), and there is the perception that the assessment of TILs is subject to great interobserver variability.
We studied interobserver agreement on the categorization of TILs; 20 cases of primary cutaneous malignant melanoma with a vertical growth phase component were circulated among 3 pathologists and 3 dermatologists. For each case, TILs were classified as brisk, nonbrisk, or absent according to Clark. Only 1 pathologist (a dermatopathologist) was familiar with the classification of TILs. Observers were given written guidelines and a brief tutorial before their examination of the slides. Our results show that with little instruction, overall agreement among observers was good (kappa values, 0.6 or more), especially among pathologists (kappa values, > 0.7). Three observers had excellent agreement among each other (kappa values, > 0.75).
These findings suggest that the categorization of TILs can be easily taught and can be applied with an acceptable level of reproducibility in routine diagnostic practice.
Vascular Involvement in the Prognosis of Primary Cutaneous Melanoma
Mohammed Kashani-Sabet, MD; Richard W. Sagebiel, MD; Carlos M. M. Ferreira, MD; Mehdi Nosrati, BS; James R. Miller III, PhD
Arch Dermatol. 2001;137:1169-1173 Abstract quote
To examine the role of vascular invasion as a prognostic factor in melanoma.
Retrospective survival analysis.
Academic medical center.
A total of 526 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma from the University of California, San Francisco, Melanoma Center database with 2 years of follow-up or documented relapse. Main
(1) Presence of vascular involvement defined as vascular invasion with tumor cells within blood or lymphatic vessels; or uncertain vascular invasion, with melanoma cells immediately adjacent to the endothelium. (2) Percentage with metastasis or death and relapse-free and overall survival.
The presence of either type of vascular involvement significantly increased the risk of relapse and death and reduced the survival associated with melanoma. The impact of vascular involvement on these outcomes was similar to that of ulceration. In a multivariate analysis, vascular involvement was the second most important factor (after tumor thickness) in the primary tumor in predicting survival.
Vascular involvement is an important independent predictor of metastasis and survival in melanoma. The phenomenon of uncertain vascular invasion describes an earlier step than definite vascular invasion in tumor progression.
Of patients with a melanoma, another will develop in 1.2-8.2%
Arch Surg 1985;120:115-1159
Ann Surg 1990;212:173-177
Among patients surviving more than 10 years after primary surger, 7-25% develop late recurrences
Non-familial cases 3% develop second melanomas within 3 years
Familial cases 33% develop second melanomas within 5 years
The pathogenesis of local recurrence of melanoma at the primary excision site.
Heenan PJ, Ghaznawie M.
Department of Pathology, Hasanuddin University, Ujungpandang, Indonesia.
Br J Plast Surg 1999 Apr;52(3):209-13 Abstract quote
Local recurrence of melanoma at the primary excision site may imply that the primary excision was incomplete or 'inadequate', and that the recurrence was due to retained primary melanoma cells or occult microsatellites in the adjacent tissue. Pathologists frequently report these tumours in the scar as recurrent or residual melanoma, without further qualification, apparently without considering the possibility that they may be metastases and manifestations of systemic disease.
In this study, 17 of 19 cases of locally recurrent melanoma at the primary excision site showed the histological features of metastasis rather than residual incompletely excised primary melanoma.
Because the prevention of local recurrence is the main reason given in recommendations for wide excision of melanoma beyond complete excision of the primary tumour itself, it is essential that surgeons and pathologists should classify these neoplasms precisely as either persistent incompletely excised primary melanoma or metastatic melanoma.
Outcome of patients with melanoma and histologically negative sentinel lymph nodes.
Gadd MA, Cosimi AB, Yu J, Duncan LM, Yu L, Flotte TJ, Souba WW, Ott MJ, Wong LS, Sober AJ, Mihm MC, Haluska FG, Tanabe KK.
Department of Surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA.
Arch Surg 1999 Apr;134(4):381-7 Abstract quote
HYPOTHESIS: Patients with melanoma and histologically negative sentinel lymph nodes identified by lymphatic mapping have a very good prognosis.
DESIGN: Cohort study with follow-up information obtained from medical records and telephone interviews.
SETTING AND PATIENTS: Of all patients with cutaneous melanoma who underwent intraoperative sentinel lymph node mapping between November 15, 1993, and April 18, 1997, at the Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, 89 were found to have no evidence of melanoma in their sentinel nodes. Forty-six lesions (51%) were on an extremity and 44 (49%) were of axial location. The median tumor thickness was 1.8 mm (range, 0.36-12.0 mm) and 11 tumors (12%) were ulcerated.
INTERVENTIONS: Patients underwent intraoperative sentinel lymph node mapping with lymphazurin and radiolabeled sulfur colloid. Sentinel lymph nodes were analyzed by standard hematoxylin-eosin staining. Only 2 patients received adjuvant therapy following wide excision of the primary lesion.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Site of initial recurrence and time to initial recurrence.
RESULTS: The median follow-up for all patients was 23 months (range, 2-54 months). Eleven patients (12%) developed melanoma recurrences, and 78 (88%) patients remain disease free. Regional lymph nodes were the initial site of recurrence in 7 (8%) of 89 patients, and 7 (7%) of 106 mapped basins. Four patients had recurrence without involvement of regional lymph nodes: 2 with distant metastases and 2 with in transit metastases. The median time to recurrence was 12 months (range, 2-35 months). Sentinel lymph nodes were reanalyzed using serial sections and immunoperoxidase stains in 7 patients with recurrence and metastatic melanoma was identified in 3 (43%).
CONCLUSIONS: The risk for melanoma recurrence is relatively low in patients with histologically negative sentinel nodes identified by lymphatic mapping. Longer follow-up will improve our understanding of the prognostic value of this procedure.
Cutaneous melanoma. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: JB Lippincott; 1992. p. 200-12.
10YR cure rate 90% <1.5 mm in thickness
<50% survival with 3 mm in thickness
<50% to 75% of patients >4mm in thickness
Stage IV disease 5-17.9% with a median survival of 6 months
(T1-2, N0) have 10 YRS of 85%
(T3-4, N0) have 10 YRS of 50%
Stage III have 10 YRS of <25%
METASTASIS Desmoplastic Melanomas
World J Surg 1992;16:186-90.
Series of 58 patients, 17 patients were noted to have local recurrence with the primary site of involvement on the head and neck
Eleven of these patients progressed to wider dissemination
No relationship between the site and histologic pattern of the primary lesion in those patients with lymph node metastasis
Elective lymphadenectomy was performed in 6 patients, all of whom had negative pathology
For those who had visceral disease, the major sites of involvement were liver, bone, brain, lung, spine, para-aortic nodes, and general dissemination
Melanomas with predominant neurotropism had a low incidence of visceral metastasis
However, those with evidence of neural transformation (ie, tumors that develop a neural appearance) without neurotropism appeared to have a high incidence of local recurrence and the potential for visceral recurrence rather than perineural and intraneural invasion
Rate of lymph node metastases of 14% appears to be lower compared with 37% for nondesmoplastic melanomas
Patients with a median tumor thickness of 6.5 mm (range, 2.15-11 mm) had lymph node recurrence, visceral recurrence, or cranial nerve neuropathies, whereas those without systemic recurrence had a median thickness of 3.6 mm (range, 0.45-16 mm)
Ann Surg 1981;194:108-112
Defined as discrete nests of melanoma cells that are noncontiguous and clearly separated from the main body of tumor by normal reticular dermal collagen or subcutaneous fat and are detected histologically
Overall, prognosis of patients is similar to that of patients with macrosatellites and should be categorized as stage III
Melanoma metastatic to "lipomata".
Mann BD, Finck SJ, Cohchran AJ, Morton DL.
J Surg Oncol 1984 Feb;25(2):98-9 Abstract quote
Three patients presented with solitary melanoma metastases that mimicked a simple "lipomata." On further investigation each patient had a discrete fatty tissue tumor mass surrounding a melanoma metastasis.
The presence of an enlarging mass in patients with a history of melanoma should be viewed with suspicion and a biopsy should be performed.
Presence of microsatellites is highly correlated with occult regional lymph node metastases in multivariate analysis
Arch Surg 1991;126:1461-1468
Compared with matched controls, microsatellite patients had a significantly decreased disease-free survival (27% versus 60% at 10 years) and decreased overall survival (37% versus 65% at 10 years)
5 YRS was 36% for patients with microsatellites versus 89% for patients without
Each scheduled visit should include:
Complete history and physical examination
Complete blood count
Liver function tests
Serum lactic dehydrogenase level
If one or more tests are abnormal, additional sophisticated testing should be performed
Stage I Annually Stage II Every 6 months for 2 years, then annually thereafter Stage III Every 3 months for 1 year, every 4 months for the second year, and every 6 months for years 3-5 All patients Annual visits from year 6 onward
Rosai J. Ackerman's Surgical Pathology. Eight Edition. Mosby 1996.
Sternberg S. Diagnostic Surgical Pathology. Third Edition. Lipincott Williams and Wilkins 1999.
Weedon D. Weedon's Skin Pathology. Churchill Livingstone. 1997.
Fitzpatrick's Dermatology in General Medicine. 5th Edition. McGraw-Hill. 1999.
Robbins Pathologic Basis of Disease. Sixth Edition. WB Saunders 1999.
Last Updated 8/16/2002
mail to firstname.lastname@example.org with
questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2002 The Doctor's Doctor